FREE SHIPPING | Orders over $200* |
Sign Up for Exclusive News + Offers
Hoegger Online Shopping Cart - Inside Your Cart

Momma Knows Best – Broody Hens

Momma Knows Best – Broody Hens

So let’s set the scene here. You go out to your chicken coop one day, and open the door to collect eggs. There, in the nest box, is one of your hens. You reach down to slide the eggs from under her, but as you get close enough to touch her, she puffs up her feathers, spreads her wings slightly, and screeches out an angry “Puck-AAARRRGGGH!”


What gives?


Well, congratulations. You have yourself a broody hen. This means that she has decided to ‘set’, and hatch some eggs herself.


Sometimes hens will cram so many eggs under themselves there just isn't any more room!



You have two options: you can let her set, and hatch some eggs – if you don’t have a rooster, your eggs won’t be fertile, so you’ll need to buy some fertile eggs – or you can try to ‘break’ her, meaning stop her from being broody.


It is possible to ‘break’ them of their broodiness, if you wish. There are various methods recommended, some more suspect than others, but probably the most widely used is to put her in a wire bottom metal dog crate with food and water and nothing else. Some people even add a young, enthusiastic rooster in the cage with her, the poor girl certainly won’t have any time to sit or ‘set’ with him in there!


If you decide to let her set, put her in a safe place, where she will not be in danger from passing predators, but where she has room to get up and stretch her legs now and again. Put her food and water in there, in a place where the other birds can’t get to it; this is so that you can monitor whether she actually is eating and drinking. Some broody hens are so dedicated that they forget to leave their nest!



Everything is better with your sister right by your side! Going broody in pairs is just more fun, and these two have settled themselves in a nice leafy area for protection.



Also, try and keep her away from loud noises, dogs and enquiring childrens’ hands, she’s going to be a little neurotic over those eggs, and you need to keep her quiet so that she doesn’t abandon her nest. She’s also going to be pretty cranky and wouldn’t be above pecking at whatever part of a small child comes too close!


Answers to some commonly asked questions:


  • Not all breeds go broody. Some breeds tend towards it more so than others, such as Orpingtons and Silkies.
  • A bird will go broody whether or not you have a rooster.
  • Some breeds will even go broody whether or not they have eggs; I have a Nankin hen who, in the absence of eggs, will gather small stones and set on them instead.
  • I had someone call me once and ask me for a broody hen. It is possible to have a hen who likes to go broody more often than others, but more often than not, broody tendencies are a matter of personality, not breed or anything else. It’s just the luck of the draw.
  • It’s incredible, but she just knows how to keep those eggs at the right temperature and  humidity. She’ll even pluck some breast feathers so that her bare skin can be right next to the eggs, all the better to monitor them and boost humidity.
  • A hen will hatch pretty much any kind of eggs you put under her. Chicken, guinea, duck; your imagination – and pen space! – is the limit.
  • Not all hens are good broodies. Some will suddenly change their mind, mid hatch, and abandon their nest. Best thing you can do in this situation is to keep an eye on the nest for a few hours and see if she goes back. If not, gather up those eggs and put them in an incubator.
  • If you need to make any changes to the hen’s location, or if you want to candle her eggs and remove any non-viable ones, do it at night. The hen will be sleepy, and you’re less likely to disrupt her.

Two Buff Orpingtons raising a family of chicks together.



A mother hen with chicks is pretty much one of the cutest things on earth – and the most natural. So many people only hatch with an incubator, that they forget they have the world’s best incubators right there in their own back yard. Like the old adage: Momma knows best.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  1. by dustynbob
    Comment made on: May 30 2012

    My problem with broody hens is the other hens kick her off the nest, and then she moves on and sets on a different nest, now no good eggs and she keeps moving. I will try moving her/them to the dog kennel, nix the dog; and see if they will continue to set there. I have tried before and they just quit and go back to their own nest place even though no eggs.

  2. by jmbrandal
    Comment made on: June 13 2012


    I have the same problem. I have two hens that want to brood, but the other chickens pick on them until they get out of the nesting box. I have tried to move the broody hens to a special box my husband build for brooding, but the hens freak out and won’t sit on their eggs after they are moved. VERY FRUSTRATING!!! It is also not fair. My neighbor has two hens brooding in the hen house as I write with no problems at all. lol Getting chicks the old fashion way is a mystery to me.


  3. by tkhideaway
    Comment made on: July 21 2012

    I have a persistent broody Turkey who will lay on top of hen who is laying on eggs–last night I found cracked open eggs with non viable baby ducks – so sad – they fight over nest boxes– Ive tried giving each a box with a couple of eggs in them and then they play musical nest boxed on me!! Also, my egg layers (non-fertile eggs) lay eggs during day and Ill find a hen broodin on them–nice and warm–any cause for concern if I refridge same day? Im guessing this is the natural way–and the eating eggs should be fine!? Deb

    • by admin
      Comment made on: July 24 2012

      Hi Deb, There is no health problem with a broody hen sitting on the eggs you are planning to consume.

  4. by Thecowboysgirl
    Comment made on: June 24 2013

    To the folks who talk about getting the broody to stay on the right nest ect., once mine goes broody, she goes into a cage similar to a rabbit hutch. There is just enough room in there for a roomy nest and food and water. I let her out 1x per day, she takes a dust bath, eats, drinks and poops. We do this while I am doing barn chores. When I am finished, I usher her back in and she gets back to work. 10 minutes a day maybe she is off. I leave the cage in the regular coop so she can see the other chickens and feel at home. Protects the eggs from marauding snakes and rats (who stole entire clutches out from under her before I figured this out) and prevents nest swapping. she has hatched me nearly 10 clutches this way.

You must be logged in to post a comment.